Showing posts with label Elizabeth Woodville. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Elizabeth Woodville. Show all posts

Tuesday, 1 November 2016

Merry Widows

In the middle ages, and indeed stretching well beyond that time, marriage was an economic contract. At the top end of society it was also political and very often the political considerations greatly outweighed all other factors. Needless to add the young couple had no say in the matter and for the most part would have accepted their fate without protest as they were schooled from an early age to this fate. It had even become a practice in the 15th century to betroth and marry children when they were too innocent to have any idea at all of the implications of marriage.
In those uncertain times women were often widowed at an early age and had a second chance at marriage and there is good evidence to show that once they were free from parental and political pressure they chose to marry for love. I want to look at two of those women, both high born, who chose love over other considerations once they had the opportunity. They are Catherine of France and Jacquetta of Luxembourg. They both married sons of Henry IV for their first marriages and both married for love once they became widows. What is more interesting is that the offspring of these second marriages had considerable impact on the destiny of England - indeed, the grandchildren of both women married in 1485 to found the Tudor dynasty.
Henry V was a very clear-headed and focussed man. When he succeeded his father in 1413 he resolved to claim what he believed was his French inheritance and to reinforce this claim he set his sights on marrying the daughter of the king of France. The invasion of 1415 which culminated in the improbable victory at Agincourt on October 25th actually achieved little more than to give the English a toehold in France. It was the campaigns in succeeding years that achieved the reconquest of Normandy and several of the other territories that were once part of the Angevin Empire and, in 1420, the French king, Charles VI, worn down by years of struggle and presiding over a weakened, riven kingdom, signed a treaty with Henry V. His daughter Catherine was to marry Henry and a key clause in the treaty acknowledged Henry as his heir. On the death of Charles, Henry would become king of France as well as king of England. The issue raised by Edward III in 1340 would at last be settled.
Marriage of Henry V and Catherine de Valois
Inconveniently, Charles also had a son, also Charles, who was dispossessed by the treaty. Even more inconveniently, Henry died six weeks before the ageing king Charles VI in 1422, leaving an infant son as his heir who became king of England and, nominally, king of France. Although the French might have been persuaded to accept Henry V in his prime, they had less reason to accept an unknown infant. Charles the Dauphin, later Charles VII, was a full-grown man and by right of birth, if not by treaty, the king of France. The English had a strongly led regency under Henry’s younger brother John, duke of Bedford and the English were able to control northern France for about 15 years before it began to erode and eventually collapse.
Funeral effigy of Catherine of Valois

Catherine de Valois, wife of Henry V and mother of Henry VI, was born 27 October 1401 in Paris. Her mother Isabeau of Bavaria had married Charles in 1387 and bore at least 12 children and Catherine was the youngest daughter. She had two older sisters who survived childhood. One of them, Jeanne, married the duke of Brittany and another,  became a nun. The sons fared less well. Only one, Catherine’s younger brother Charles, survived to become king of France. Several older brother died before the age of 21 and one was poisoned. When she was married to Henry V 4 June 1420 he was 14 years her senior. She gave birth to their one child on 6 December 1421 at Windsor castle. Her husband died of dysentery at Vincennes, a few miles away from Paris where she was staying at the time. She apparently made no attempt to visit him during his last hours which may tell us a lot about their relationship.
Back in England she was the queen dowager, and at first glance in a powerful position. The council were certainly mindful of that and in 1425, the three year old Henry was moved to a separate household to be brought up and educated under the care of ? (Wolfe says she had care of him until he was 7 years old) There is no evidence that Catherine raised any serious objections and it may be that she was not particularly interested in the boy. She herself had been brought up in a dysfunctional household. Her father had a strain of madness that had violent outbreaks at times and her mother was a politically ambitious woman who, despite her large brood, showed little maternal affection for them.
Catherine was rather constrained as a widow. Her remarriage held all sorts of political ramifications for the ruling council and they wanted to retain control of her. She soon fell in love with Edmund Beaufort, earl of Somerset. Like the Lancastrian kings, Beaufort was descended from Joh of Gaunt by his mistress and third wife Katherine Swynford and this liaison was regarded as politically dangerous. When Humphrey, duke of Gloucester learned of the affair and her intention to marry he intervened and the council enacted a law that no-one should marry Catherine without the consent of council. The act of 1428 stated that if the queen dowager was to marry without the king’s consent then her husband would forfeit all lands and possessions. This was sufficient to deter Edmund Beaufort.
Once that liaison had been terminated Catherine turned her attention to Owen Tudor and in the next few years bore him five children. Tudor was a welshman and a knight who had done service in France. He appears to have been appointed master of the queen’s wardrobe while she was living at Windsor castle and this brought the two into contact with one another. The first child, Edmund, was born c 1430. The couple moved to the country far from the prying eyes of court and the facts of the liaison were undiscovered for some years. Owen Tudor was granted the rights of an Englishman by Parliament in 1432, so clearly most at court were ignorant of the liaison or the children. Some say that there was a secret marriage but this is unknown; however the children were later recognised as legitimate issue.
Eventually the couple were discovered. The duke of Gloucester had Owen Tudor committed to Newgate Prison and Catherine was sent to Bermondsey Abbey, pregnant with a fifth child. Her children were put under the care of Catherine de la Pole, the abbess of Barking and a sister of the Earl of Suffolk.  The child, a daughter, died soon after birth and Catherine was seriously ill afterwards and died at the age of 36 on 3 January 1437.
After Catherine’s death Owen was accused of breaking the law by marrying the queen. He was acquitted of this charge, which would suggest that he denied that they had married. On his return to Wales however, he was arrested and sent to Newgate. his possessions were seized, which may suggest that there were those who did not believe his denial. He tried to escape in 1438 but was re-arrested and placed in Windsor Castle.
His fortunes started to change in 1439. He was pardoned by the king and released on bail of £2000, which was cancelled in 1440. 1442
Henry VI, her first son was now 16 years old and in a position to make decisions. He chose to honour his mother with a state funeral and burial in Westminster Abbey. He was surprisingly generous to his half brothers and sister. Owen Tudor was given an annuity of £40 and the two elder sons, Edmund and Jasper, were created earls of Richmond and Pembroke respectively. The third brother Owen became a monk. Further, in 1453, possibly mindful that he had not produced an heir at that time, he declared his half brothers legitimate. Edmund was married to the heiress to the House of Somerset, Margaret Beaufort. Margaret was only about 10 years old at the time of her marriage and it was customary not to begin conjugal relations too early. Edmund Tudor was impatient and soon after her first period made her pregnant. He was subsequently captured by Yorkist forces and died on 1 November 1456 of the plague whilst in prison. After his death Margaret gave birth to Henry Tudor on 28 January 1457. It was a difficult birth for an immature body and we guess that Margaret was damaged from the experience as she was never able to conceive another child. Such are the tenuous threads that make up royal history; that child was to become Henry VII. 
Perhaps Humphrey of Gloucester was right to be worried after all.

The second widow is Jacquetta of Luxembourg, daughter of the Count of St Pol, perhaps not a grand as Catherine of Valois but with a lineage which could be traced back to Charlemagne. She came to attention after John, duke of Bedford, younger brother of Henry V, and regent of France lost his first wife, Anne of Burgundy. The English position in France was weakening at the time and relations with Burgundy were precarious, so the match was proposed by Jacquetta’s uncle, the Bishop of Thérouanne. The couple were married at the bishop’s palace on 29 April 1433. She was 17 years old and contemporary reports describe her as lively and attractive. Bedford however was her senior by 27 years. He was also in declining health. His struggle to maintain the English position in France after Henry V’s death with sometimes lukewarm support from home had worn the man down. His health eventually failed him and he died on 14 February 1435.
His young widow was well provided for but, while she was not as politically important as Catherine, the king’s council made provision that she not remarry without the kin’s permission when he was granted her dower rights 6 February 1436. 
It is very difficult to assess her first marriage at a distance of almost 600 years but it is notable that the marriage of almost two years produced no issue. Jacquetta accompanied her husband in both England and France and in view of her later fecundity the absence of children with the duke is worth comment.  John did have two illegitimate children, a boy, Richard, who was alive in 1434, and a daughter Mary. She married Peter de Montserrat and died after 1458. He was unable to successfully father children by his first wife, Anne of Burgundy. He married her in 1423 and she died during childbirth (as did the infant) on 14 November 1432. It is quite possible that other unsuccessful pregnancies preceded this, but none were recorded.  Jacquetta was young and strong and without doubt capable of bearing children. Yet there was no pregnancy of record during the more the two years of their marriage, and this is a puzzle. The duke was certainly in poor health at this time but in the previous year (1433) he was still notionally potent. The couple were separated in age by 27 years; he was old enough to be her father. However he was a man past his prime and as it turned out very near to the end of his life. He had been worn down by his responsibilities in France and almost constant campaigning. He may have been at a stage in his life when he was no longer interested in the sexual act. That, together with his manifold responsibilities may have kept him and Jacquetta from enjoying a proper union. It is also possible that she had no appetite for him and they may have mutually agreed to not sharing the same bed, both content to maintain the outward show of the marriage for the diplomatic purposes behind the union.
During this period of widowhood her attention was drawn to a very good looking and athletic young knight, Sir Richard Woodville. He was probably at the time in his mid-twenties. His father had been a chamberlain to the duke of Bedford and he himself was in the duke’s service. There was a strong romantic attraction on both sides. She however was a duchess; he was of lesser status. Around this time his father inherited the Northamptonshire estates of the Woodvilles and within a few years he would also come into this inheritance. He was not badly off, but there was a large gap between their respective social status.
Nonetheless Jacquetta was determined to have her man and they married secretly, certainly before 23 March 1437 when Parliament fined the couple £1000. They paid up. Her family and authorities in England were annoyed but concluded that there was not much that could be done, which seems to hint that Jacquetta was already pregnant at the time. The baby she was carrying was born that year and may have been a boy, named Richard. He must have died in infancy because the first child to survive to adulthood, Elizabeth, was the beautiful woman who would propel the family to enduring fame, or notoriety, depending on your viewpoint. In 1464 in circumstances which would have seemed improbable to a writer of fiction, she married Edward IV, king of England.
From the successful birth of Elizabeth, Sir Richard and Jacquetta produced a large and healthy family over the next twenty years. Sir Richard in the meantime made progress in his career being appointed to various important positions. He was created a baron by Henry VI in 1448 and the family’s economic circumstances improved. Around 1440 they were able to purchase the Grafton Manor from the Duke of Suffolk.

Queen Elizabeth, wife of Edward IV
The marriage of Edward IV and Elizabeth Grey (nee Woodville) in 1464 astonished contemporaries and even today we find it equally astonishing. Elizabeth nevertheless had many qualities that fitted her for the role of queen and an objective assessment would be that she acquitted herself well. She did however have a large number of kinfolk to provide for and this caused resentment against the “Woodvilles” which was eventually to prove their undoing. Elizabeth had two sons from her first marriage, five brothers and an equal number of sisters. All were given status and the girls were matched with plum marriages. The men meanwhile, as they grew up and included members of the wider Woodville kinship formed a sizeable faction at court. The Tudors, if a comparison can be made between the two families, came to three in number, father and two sons, and were never a threat to the establishment. 
Edmund Tudor, earl of Richmond
Two high born women made a love match after they were widowed from their first arranged marriages. Both were wealthy enough to make that choice. Neither saw any destiny in this. They simply felt entitled to some happiness and were content to take a chance on love. For Jacquetta this worked out well. She was a strong and wealthy woman and bore a lot of children, all of whom turned out to be intelligent and talented. She faced tragedy late in life when her husband and one of her sons were executed by the earl of Warwick in 1469 but she was able to see her daughter crowned queen of England and her other daughters make highly placed marriages. Her sons achieved positions of some eminence. Catherine had a neglected childhood and may not have been a good mother. She did not appear to have much contact with her first born son and attended neither of his coronations, either in England or France. How she fared with her Tudor children we do not know. She seems to have found love and happiness with Owen Tudor and deliberately opted out of the political mainstream. She had no wish to model herself on her politically active mother. 


Henry Tudor
In the 1430s two knights of middling rank each married a high born widow. A grandson of one and a granddaughter of another became king and queen of England in 1485. Who could have predicted that?
Elizabeth of York

Monday, 4 July 2016

When was Elizabeth Woodville born?

I have just read a Wikipedia article which gives the date of Elizabeth Woodville's birth as 3 February 1437. Oh really? The truth is that we have no evidence at all for her date of birth and that is the case for every one of the Woodville children. We can speculate and make informed estimates but however we do this we are groping in the dark. In any case, the February 3rd date seems far too early, for reasons which I will outline.

The portrait above is attributed to John Stratford who was appointed by Edward IV as the King's painter in 1461. The attribution was made by William A. Shaw in a 1934 article for the Burlington Magazine about Early English Portraiture. As an expert in this field he was may have been right about the approximate date, based on stylistic analysis and given the tools at his disposal in 1934, but in more recent times other experts have questioned the originality of the work and it is suggested that the portrait is a copy of a lost original.

Now the interesting piece of information for the historian is the inscription in the top left corner in gold lettering. It is not clear in this image but it reads: "Aetat SVE 26, Anno Dom 1463." which translates as: "Aged herself 26, 1463." That seems clear enough and we can deduce that she was born in 1437, that she was 27 when she married the 22 year old Edward IV, and that she was 42 years old when she gave birth to her last child Bridget in 1479. This is all quite plausible and 1437 is the generally accepted date for her birth.

However, I would like to raise a flag. 1463 seems a highly unlikely date for the portrait to be painted. At the time she was the widow Grey and probably not on the king's radar. Even if he was showing interest in 1463, arranging for her portrait would have been a highly public and expensive undertaking and given the secrecy of the wedding in 1464 would seem to be quite unwise. In any case she would have been known as Lady Grey at that date. It would be more plausible if the portrait was undertaken after the marriage and prior to the coronation, therefore at any time between October 1464 and may 1465 and one would lean to 1465 as the preferred date. If indeed it was painted as early as this at all.

This portrait resembles in its pose several other extant portraits of the queen and it is likely that the original of these was painted after 1471, when Edward returned to the throne. The earliest surviving painting, from the royal collection, now in the Ashmolean Museum, is thought to have been painted between 1513 and 1530, and all of the other portraits are, like this one, much more precise and skilfully painted than the Ashmolean portrait.
Elizabeth Woodvile from the Ashmoleum Museum, painted c 1513-1530
A further mystery surrounding the painting at the top of this article is that it was owned by William Shaw himself, apparently, and its whereabouts today is unknown. The only evidence of it is a colour photograph in the Connoisseur Magazine published in 1911.

So we have to ask ourselves if we can take any of this 'evidence' seriously. Dr William Shaw was a respected academic but it does now seem odd that this portrait has never come to light. Queens' College are quite polite about this: 'The portrait has never been reported by anyone other than Dr Shaw, and its present whereabouts are unknown.' However, being less well-mannered, I am inclined to ask if this was ever a genuine portrait, but merely a copy made by someone in the 20th century with the inscription that communicated the message that the generator of this page intended. This was after all the era of the Piltdown Man and the Loch Ness Monster, and Sir Arthur Conan Doyle fell for some contrived photographs that purported to show fairies at the bottom of the garden. Have no basis other than a suspicious mind to make any accusation against Dr Shaw but I don't think we should put any energy into trying to explain these dates.

Which brings me back to the beginning. We really do not know when Elizabeth was born.
We have one date to guide us and that is 23 March 1437, when Duchess Jacquetta and Sir Richard Woodville were fined £1000 for marrying without the king's permission. The duchess was noticeably pregnant at the time so an earlier union must be presumed. We could suppose that the first child was born later that year.

But was it Elizabeth? Antony we believe from other evidence was born c 1440, although that could have been as late as 1442. He was definitely the eldest male to survive childhood. Elizabeth is also believed to be the eldest daughter and the birth of two sons by  her first marriage would support that view. Her eldest, Thomas, was probably born c 1455, and while some argument can be made for 1452, the later date is more likely. If we take 1455, that would make Elizabeth 18 at the birth of her first child, which seems lateish. Were she born in 1439, she would then be 16.

Bear in mind that she was probably married as a child. Her sister Jacquetta was married in 1450 and it seems to me that must assume that Elizabeth was married to John Grey either at the same time or earlier. It cannot be, in my view, that younger daughters were married before older sisters. This being the case, she probably moved to the Grey household and lived there until the pair were old enough to consummate the marriage. We should take into account too that the later disputed grant of three manors to the young Greys was made in 1456, probably after the birth of the first son and in expectation of a second. This should also incline us to a 1455 year of birth for Thomas Grey.

I should also mention in this context that there were some other Woodville children who probably died young. A fragmentary note written by Robert Glover, a herald in the 1567, lists the children of the Woodville family and in addition to those we know about there was a second  Richard, a Louis and another John. As there was both a John and a Richard who lived to adulthood we might guess that these other boys died young. Richard, of course, would be an expected name for the first-born son. Sir Richard Woodville's father was Richard, and it was entirely conventional to name the first born son after the paternal grandparent. Louis was probably named after Jacquetta's brother, who by this time was Count of St Pol. So there is room for at least two births before 1439. Could they both have been boys?

Possible of course but pure speculation. I do however incline to a 1439 date  for Elizabeth's birth. If she were born in 1437 she would be a full five years older than Edward and that has always seemed a lot to me, particularly t that age. Edward was 22 in 1464 and five years was practically a quarter of his life. Three years might seem a lot less.
The only definitive statement we can make about the birth year of Elizabeth Woodville is that we don't know it and may never know it.